Skip to main content
Casullo Collectibles

Casullo Collectibles

1.2K items sold
53 followers
Contact

Featured categories

Newly Listed

See all

  • 2021 Panini Elite Amon-Ra St. Brown Pen Pals Auto Purple Ink Rookie Detroit Lion

    $124.95

  • 2015-2016 Upper Deck Jack Eichel Flair Showcase Fleer Rookie Jersey Sabre Knight

    $10.95

  • 2020-21 Upper Deck Allure Andrei Vasilevskiy White Diamond /50 Retail Tampa Bay

    $49.95

  • 2021 Panini Prizm Jaylen Waddle Red White Blue Rookie PSA 10 Miami Dolphins RC

    $74.95

  • 2023 Panini Prizm CJ Stroud Silver Variation Rookie Card Houston Texans RC 302

    $424.95

  • 2020 Panini Illusions Justin Herbert Mystique Red /149 PSA 9 MINT Charger Rookie

    $199.95

It's Hockey Season!

Hockey Season

Shop now
It's Hockey Season!

All items

2005 SP Authentic Future Watch Thomas Vanek Rookie BGS 9.5 Auto 10 Buffalo Sabre

$69.95

2022 Panini Select Dalton Kincaid XRC Tie-Dye Prizm /25 Redemption TE1 Bills RC

$624.95

2020 Panini Prizm Justin Jefferson Purple Pulsar Rookie PSA 9 Minnesota Vikings

$749.95

2021 Panini Spectra Josh Allen Neon Orange Prizm Die-Cut /10 PSA 8 Buffalo Bills

$124.95

2020 Panini Illusions Joe Burrow Trophy Collection Orange Rookie PSA 10 MINT RC

$184.95

2020 Panini Select Stefon Diggs Club Level Cosmic Prizm SSP Vikings Bills Texans

$124.95

2023 Panini Illusions CJ Stroud Trophy Collection Dots Rookie Houston Texans RC

$99.95

2009 Playoff Contenders LeSean Shady McCoy Rookie Ticket AUTO Eagles PSA 9 RC

$124.95

2022 Panini Contenders James Cook Rookie Ticket Stub Auto /28 Buffalo Bills RC

$174.95

2018 Playbook Split 6 Signature Josh Allen Lamar Jackson Rookie /15 BGS 9 Auto

$8,374.95

2020-21 Upper Deck Allure Andrei Vasilevskiy White Diamond /50 Retail Tampa Bay

$49.95

2023 Panini Prizm CJ Stroud Silver Variation Rookie Card Houston Texans RC 302

$424.95

2022 Upper Deck Owen Power Black Diamond Rookie Gems Auto /25 Buffalo Sabres RC

$224.95

2021 Panini Select Stefon Diggs Premier Level Orange Pulsar Prizm FOTL /7 Texans

$119.95

2022 Panini Limited Josh Allen & Stefon Diggs Dynamic Duos Emerald Dual Patch /5

$399.95

2016-17 Leaf In the Game Jack Eichel Mike Modano Reflection Dual Jersey Patch /5

$24.95

2021 Panini Elite Amon-Ra St. Brown Pen Pals Auto Purple Ink Rookie Detroit Lion

$124.95

2021 Panini Select James Cook XRC Rookie Gold Prizm /10 Buffalo Bills RC SSP 408

$499.95

2020 Panini Select Joe Burrow Field Level Orange Prizm Die-Cut BGS 9.5 Rookie RC

$399.95

2023 Panini Prizm CJ Stroud PSA 9 MINT Houston Texans RC #339 Rookie of the Year

$99.95

2018 Panini Playbook Josh Allen Rookie Patch Auto Jersey RPA /49 Buffalo Bill RC

$1,124.95

2020 Panini Contenders Tre'Davious White Veteran Ticket Auto Printing Plate 1/1

$499.95

2018 Panini Illusions Josh Allen & Jim Kelly PSA 9 MINT Rookie Buffalo Bills RC

$99.95

2020 Josh Allen Flawless Star Swatch Signatures /10 BGS 9 Auto 10 Buffalo Bills

$2,374.95

2021 Panini Prizm Jaylen Waddle Red White Blue Rookie PSA 10 Miami Dolphins RC

$74.95

2016 The Cup O'Reilly Eichel Reinhart Trios Jersey Patch /25 & Blank Back Proof

$39.95

Vintage Samuel Adams Brewing Logo Large Blue T-Shirt Sam Brewer Patriot Boston

$19.95

2019 Panini Select Ed Oliver Concourse Level Rookie Cosmic Prizm Buffalo Bill RC

$99.95

2009 Playoff Contenders LeSean McCoy Rookie Ticket AUTO Eagles Bills PSA 10 RC

$374.95

2015-2016 Upper Deck Jack Eichel Flair Showcase Fleer Rookie Jersey Sabre Knight

$10.95

2021 Panini Select Stefon Diggs Snapshots Tie-Dye Prizm Parallel /25 Bill Texans

$94.95

2015-2016 Jack Eichel Fleer Showcase Hot Prospects Rookie Jersey Patch /299 RC

$29.95

2019 2020 Coby White Mosaic Fast Break PSA 10 RC Chicago Bulls NBA Debut Rookie

$99.95

1998-1999 Paul Pierce Topps Finest Rookie PSA 10 GEM MINT Boston Celtics #235 RC

$99.95

2016-2017 UD Jack Eichel SP Game-Used Jersey Patch Buffalo Sabres Vegas Knights

$10.95

2020 Panini Select Josh Allen Club Level ZEBRA Prizm Parallel SSP Buffalo Bills

$324.95

2018 Panini One Andre Reed 4-Color Patch On Card Auto Bronze /49 Buffalo Bills

$124.95

2018 National Treasures Bruce Smith Peerless Signs Auto /25 PSA 9 Buffalo Bills

$249.95

Vintage AC/DC Back In Black T-Shirt Adult Graphic Tee Men's Large Music Band L

$19.95

2020 Panini Contenders Tre'Davious White Veteran Ticket Auto Clear /10 Bill Rams

$199.95

2022 Panini Prizm Garrett Wilson Emergent No Huddle Silver Prizm CSG 10 GEM MINT

$124.95

2017 2018 Alex Tuch Rookie Patch Auto Acetate Platinum Blue /25 BGS 9 Auto 10 RC

$349.95

2021 Panini Select Stefon Diggs Premier Level Cosmic Prizm SSP Bills Texans

$119.95

2021 Upper Deck Clear Cut Foundations Rasmus Dahlin Dylan Cozens Buffalo Sabres

$34.95

2016-2017 UD SPx Jack Eichel Extravagant Material Game-Used Jersey Patch Vegas

$10.95

2016-17 Ultimate Jack Eichel Numeric Excellence Game-Used Dual Patch /35 Sabres

$10.95

2016-2017 UD Jack Eichel SP Game-Used Jersey 3-Color Patch Buffalo Sabres /25 SP

$34.95

2020 Panini Mosaic Jalen Hurts Reactive Orange PSA 10 GEM MINT 222 Rookie Eagles

$124.95
Items Per Page
See All

About us

Welcome to our eBay Store! We are a family operation and we have been selling and buying on eBay since February 1998. Please add us to your list of favorite sellers and visit often. Thank you for your business!
Location: United StatesMember since: Feb 28, 1998Seller: casullo.collectibles

Feedback ratings

Last 12 months

Positive31- positive feedback in last 12 months
Neutral0- neutral feedback in last 12 months
Negative0- negative feedback in last 12 months

Detailed seller ratings

Average for the last 12 months

Accurate description
5.0
Reasonable shipping cost
5.0
Shipping speed
5.0
Communication
5.0

Seller feedback (730)

c***a (1373)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
🌟 Absolutely stellar experience! ⏰ Prompt delivery, 📦 item exactly as described, and 📞 great communication. Highly recommend this seller! 👍💫
c***a (1373)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
🌟 Absolutely stellar experience! ⏰ Prompt delivery, 📦 item exactly as described, and 📞 great communication. Highly recommend this seller! 👍💫
p***e (163)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past month
Verified purchase
Fast shipping and item well packaged to prevent damage. A+ seller.
y***t (853)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past year
Verified purchase
Fast shipping, item as described, well packaged - easy and pleasant transaction
g***2 (583)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Card arrived as described! A+++ seller!!
7***2 (761)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Fast shipping/well packaged/would do business again
See all feedback