Skip to main content
CollegeFanCave

CollegeFanCave

61K items sold
676 followers
Contact

Featured categories

Extra 20% off 5 or more items

20% off raw cards under $20

Shop now
Extra 20% off 5 or more items

All items

JAMES MADISON DUKES STUFFED PLUSH SPIRIT NAME DISPLAY 42" LONG! HERRINGTON

$24.99

2022 Topps Chrome Update George Kirby /250 Aqua Refractor #USC101 ⚾ RC

$9.9920% off 5+

2023 Topps Silver Pattern Foil #206 Gunnar Henderson RC ⚾ CGC 10 Pristine POP 1

$150.00

HERRINGTON TEDDY BEARS PETIT FOURS "GET WELL SOON" PLUSH STUFFED TEDDY BEAR 4"

$6.99

2019 Topps Allen & Ginter's Mini A & G Logo Back Vladimir Guerrero Jr. #192 ⚾ RC

$6.9920% off 5+

FLORIDA STATE SEMINOLES STUFFED PLUSH FOOTBALL 6" HERRINGTON BEARS

$9.99Save up to 20% when you buy more

2013 Topps Chrome STEVE SMITH Veteran Auto Refractor Rare PANTHERS

$150.00

2023 Topps Chrome Kody Clemens /99 Green Refractor RC #135 SGC 10 GEM MINT

$39.99

New York Yankees 29" x 43" Vertical Double-Sided Jersey House Flag

$24.99Save up to 20% when you buy more

LOT OF (5) 2013 Topps Chrome #33 Marcell Ozuna RC ⚾

$9.9920% off 5+

KENTUCKY WILDCATS STUFFED PLUSH SPIRIT NAME "KENTUCKY" PILLOW DISPLAY 28" LONG

$19.99Save up to 20% when you buy more

Team Sports America Pittsburgh Pirates Bam Vino Baseball Wine Bottle Holder Gift

$45.00

2015 Panini Prizm Draft Picks Camo Prizm #6 Alshon Jeffery #/199 🏈

$3.9920% off 5+

2014 TOPPS CHROME REFRACTOR DAVANTE ADAMS RC #114 PACKERS

$14.9920% off 5+

2018 National Treasures #126 College Materials Nyheim Hines /99 🏈 Auto Go Pack

$14.9920% off 5+

RUTGERS SCARLET KNIGHTS STUFFED PLUSH SPIRIT NAME DISPLAY 22" HERRINGTON

$19.99Save up to 20% when you buy more

2023 Topps National Convention Bowman Chrome #MLB-23 Anthony Volpe ⚾ RC

$9.9920% off 5+

Kansas City Royals Bam Vino Baseball Wine Bottle Holder Gift Team Sports America

$45.00

Georgia Bulldogs Team Mascot Plush Mascot 11" UGA

$22.99Save up to 20% when you buy more

Washington Redskins Logo Grilling Apron Team Sports America

$49.99

2018 Panini Prizm DJ MOORE RC LAZER PRIZM #207 PANTHERS

$24.99

KENTUCKY WILDCATS LOGO PLUSH MASCOT 8" HERRINGTON TEDDY BEARS

$19.99Save up to 20% when you buy more

2022 Topps Gold Label Class 1 #49 - Bobby Witt Jr. ⚾ RC

$6.9920% off 5+

Team Sports America San Francisco Giants Bam Vino Baseball Wine Bottle Holder

$45.00

2000 Collector's Edge T3 Brian Urlacher /999 #161 RC HOF BEARS

$9.9920% off 5+

2015 Panini Prizm Draft Picks Red Power Prizm #78 Odell Beckham Jr. 🏈

$3.9920% off 5+

2023 Topps Allen & Ginter Framed Mini Autographs #MA-ML Moisés Lopez Auto

$9.99

MONKEY HEAD MANDRILL CHRISTMAS ORNAMENT 2.5" SLAVIC TREASURES

$6.99

HERRINGTON TEDDY BEARS LIMITED EDITION RODEO COWBOY BEAR AMERICAN TRAVEL RARE

$19.99

VANDERBILT COMMODORES STUFFED PLUSH PILLOW 10X14" HERRINGTON COLLEGE COLLECTION

$29.99

2019 Topps Update 150TH Blue #150-44 Greatest Players Vladimir Guerrero Jr. ⚾ RC

$6.9920% off 5+

NOTRE DAME FIGHTING IRISH PLUSH TEDDY BEAR W/ LETTERMAN JACKET HERRINGTON

$29.99

KENT STATE GOLDEN FLASHES STUFFED PLUSH SPIRIT NAME DISPLAY 30" LONG! HERRINGTON

$19.99

2014 Panini Prizm Red White & Blue Prizm #8 Bruce Smith 🏈 HOF

$3.9920% off 5+

2015 PANINI GEORGIA BULLDOGS COMPLETE BASE SET 1-49

$9.9920% off 5+

2008 Topps Allen & Ginter's #297 - Max Scherzer ⚾ RC

$9.9920% off 5+

2012 Bowman Sterling Rookie Patch Auto Luke Kuechly BSAR-LK 🏈 RC Thick RPA

$79.99

LOT OF (5) 2022 Topps Allen & Ginter #203 Bobby Witt Jr. RC

$14.9920% off 5+

LOT OF (10) 2019 Bowman Kyle Tucker #94 RC

$6.9920% off 5+

2012 Topps Chrome Blue Wave Refractors #BW-45 Luke Kuechly 🏈 RC

$29.99

*SAMPLE SALE* KENTUCKY WILDCATS PEPPERMINT DESIGN LIGHTWEIGHT ORNAMENT 3"

$7.99Save up to 20% when you buy more

2015 Score Brett Hundley Rookie Helmets Patch Relic #20

$2.9920% off 5+

Oswego Lakers Men's Hockey PLUSH TEDDY BEAR HERRINTON BEARS SUNY Oswego

$19.99

Los Angeles Rams NFL Tall Mascot Christmas Ornament Rampage Team Sports America

$16.99Save up to 20% when you buy more

2021 Topps X Mickey Mantle Collection Orange #MM49 2020 Topps #/150⚾ HOF

$9.9920% off 5+

ROOKIE LOT OF (5) 2021 Topps Update Series Tarik Skubal #US284 RC TIGERS

$3.9920% off 5+

2018 Topps Archives - Topps Coins #C-20 Hamilton "Ham" Porter ⚾ The Sandlot

$9.9920% off 5+

2006 Topps Allen & Ginter's Mini #279 Stan Musial ⚾ HOF

$7.9920% off 5+
Items Per Page
See All

About us

Welcome to CollegeFanCave. We carry unique gift items from your favorite team as well as sports cards and memorabilia. Click on your favorite team in our categories section below. Our entire store offers $3.99 flat rate shipping You will never spend more than 3.99 on shipping for as many items as you like! Make sure to add items to your cart prior to checkout to receive the discount.

New! Volume discounts across all eligible items. Add items with this icon to your cart to receive the discount.

We are constantly adding new items that are eligible for this discount. You don’t have to buy multiple of the same item. Mix and match from our many offerings.
Location: United StatesMember since: Nov 11, 2009Seller: collegefancavecfc

Feedback ratings

Last 12 months

Positive1,216- positive feedback in last 12 months
Neutral7- neutral feedback in last 12 months
Negative2- negative feedback in last 12 months

Detailed seller ratings

Average for the last 12 months

Accurate description
5.0
Reasonable shipping cost
5.0
Shipping speed
5.0
Communication
5.0

Seller feedback (24,690)

t***c (1637)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past year
Verified purchase
Great ornament exactly as described in the listing looked even better in person. Fast shipping; packed carefully and securely to withstand the journey through the postal system without damage. Great communication and very smooth transaction with this highly recommended seller. A+ eBay experience!
i***a (254)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Card was delivered in great shape just as described, packing was very secure. Would do business with them again and the price and shipping was reasonable.
u***y (1651)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Great service. Fast delivery and no issues at all. Communication was awesome and the item came securely packaged. Return customer
n***7 (541)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Nice card, exactly as described with fast, reasonably priced shipping. Excellent seller, Thank you!!!
c***1 (1817)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Awesome item, great price, excellent customer service, securely packaged, and fast shipping! Thank you!
c***1 (1817)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Awesome item, great price, excellent customer service, securely packaged, and fast shipping! Thank you!
See all feedback