Skip to main content
Lost Lovey Store

Lost Lovey Store

17K items sold
255 followers
Contact

Featured categories

Newly Listed

See all

  • Pottery Barn Pillow Sham Stonington Paisley Euro New

    $29.99

  • Aurora Swirl the Squirrel Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Brown 12" New Lopsie Lulus

    $39.99

  • Parents Choice Deer Fawn Security Blanket Baby Lovey Brown Plush

    $24.99

  • Vintage Infantino Giraffe Terrycloth Plush Baby Rattle Lovey Toy Blue Rare

    $39.99

  • Saranoni Baby Blanket Blue Luxe Faux Fur Satin Trim Plush

    $39.99

  • Angel Dear Monkey Security Blanket Baby Lovey Pair Brown Lot of 2 Plush

    $19.99

All items

Passover Needlepoint Canvas Judaica Jewish Art Made in Austria Vintage

$11.9940% off

Bucilla Plastic Canvas Kit Gaggle of Geese Door Draftstop Wall Hanging Sealed

$12.7415% off

80 Fun World Vtg Halloween Paper Trick Treat Goody Bags Bat Cat Pumpkin 1995

$10.4930% off

North American Bear Company Giraffe Security Blanket Baby Cozies Lovey Hot Socks

$13.2930% off

Garanimals Elephant Baby Lovey Gray Green Plush Stuffed Toy 9"

$10.4930% off

Baby Gear Monkey Security Blanket Lovey Star Plush Fleece

$11.8930% off

Baby Starters Sock Monkey Security Blanket Lovey Dream Big Little One Plush

$10.4930% off

Softies Santa and Mrs. Claus Soft Sculpture Faces Kits Vintage Christmas Craft

$12.5930% off

Taggies Deer Flora Fawn Security Blanket Baby Lovey Plush Purple Floral

$12.5930% off

Vitamins Pink Horse Security Blanket Baby Lovey Plush Paisley Small

$25.4915% off

SDA Vtg Adventist Hospital Chefs Cookbook Dining Delightfully Vegetarian Recipes

$40.7915% off

Lillypost Plush Fox Stuffed Animal Toy Small 5"

$12.99

Iwatobi Swim Club Makoto Doll 9" Anime Great Eastern Entertainment Soft

$10.4930% off

Nordstrom Baby Blanket Pink White Chenille Plush Rare Design

$27.9930% off

Pottery Barn Pillow Sham Stonington Paisley Euro New

$29.99

Blankets & Beyond White Bear Security Baby Lovey Plush Rosettes Swirls

$11.9940% off

Nuby Bunny Security Blanket Baby Lovey White Pink Plush

$16.7940% off

Angel Dear Monkey Security Blanket Baby Lovey Pair Brown Lot of 2 Plush

$19.99

Taggies Security Blanket Baby Lovey Bunny Print Gray Pink

$15.2915% off

Vintage 1980s Hallmark Scene Setters 3D Yellow Shadow Box Woodland Critters

$14.9940% off

Jellycat Bashful Teddy Bear US Open Lovey Stuffed Animal Medium 12" Tan Honey

$11.9940% off

Vintage NFL JC Penney Curtain Panel Fabric Houston Oilers Football

$14.9940% off

Needlepoint Canvas Rabbi with Torah Judaica Jewish Made in Austria Vintage

$13.9930% off

Build A Bear Blue Sleeping Bag Camping Lizards Bugs BABW

$8.9940% off

Mary Meyer HORSE Loosey Goosey 10" Brown Plush Toy Stuffed Animal Lovey Small

$10.4930% off

Princess Soft Toys Plush Elephant Baby Lovey Stuffed Animal Safari Blue Purple

$8.9940% off

Little Giraffe BABY LOVE Blanket Luxe Faux Fur Satin Trim Plush Dusty Pink New

$74.99

Parents Choice Deer Fawn Security Blanket Baby Lovey Brown Plush

$24.99

Martha Stewart Frame Border Punch Cartridge DECO FAN Paper Crafts

$12.99

Carters Just One You Baby Blanket Pink Green Flowers Vine Style J4153 Plush

$29.99

Shopkins Candy Apple Purple Plush Stuffed Toy Rare New

$17.9940% off

Blankets and Beyond Pink Bunny Security Baby Lovey Gray Eyes Nose Rosette Swirl

$11.9940% off

Camp Kitties Snow Leopard Plush Toy Stuffed Animal Alexon Group 11"

$19.5930% off

Carters Just One Year Puppy Baby Lovey Rattle Plush Prestige Tan Blue Check Bow

$11.9940% off

Willow Tree Figurine Madonna & Child 2000 SUSAN LORDI Mom Mother and Baby

$22.9415% off

Stephan Baby Bear Security Blanket Baby Lovey Blue Satin Trim Plush New

$14.9940% off

Aurora Swirl the Squirrel Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Brown 12" New Lopsie Lulus

$39.99

Snoopy Plush Puppy Dog Peanuts Worldwide 2021 Stuffed Animal 8"

$11.9940% off

Camp Kitties Cheetah Leopard Plush Toy Stuffed Animal Alexon Group 11"

$19.5930% off

Kellytoy Elephant Security Blanket Baby Lovey Plush Pink Ribbon Tags Polka Dots

$14.9940% off

Saranoni Baby Blanket Blue Luxe Faux Fur Satin Trim Plush

$39.99

Vintage Christmas Ornament Push Pin Pink Green Gold Sequins Pearls Handmade MCM

$11.9940% off

Jellycat Rumpus Puppy Dog Rattle Cream Brown Spots Small 8" Plush Baby Lovey Toy

$25.4915% off

Russ Harold Hedgehog with Flower Mini Plush Small 4" Stuffed Animal Toy Brown

$9.99

Gund Dog Plush White Black Spots Plaid Bow 41333 Stuffed Animal Toy

$17.9940% off

Baby Gund Twiddle Giraffe Plush Musical Lovey Toy Yellow 58455

$27.9930% off

Judaica Needlepoint Canvas Young Man Boy with Book Palm Branch Vintage Austria

$11.9940% off

Mary Meyer APE Sweet Rascals Gorilla Plush Black Brown Stuffed Animal Toy Monkey

$34.99
Items Per Page
See All

About us

Welcome to The Lost Lovey Store! I'm here to help you find that item your child just can't live without! I offer baby blankets, security blankets, baby loveys, plush toys, and stuffed animals--things that are so important to our little ones. My inventory usually contains vintage baby blankets and plush toys as well, because no matter how old we get, sometimes it's delightful to have a nostalgic piece of our childhood. Can't find what you're looking for? Let me know, and I might be able to help you. Check back often; I add new inventory almost every day!
Location: United StatesMember since: Oct 07, 2001Seller: adorable*and*affordable
Top Rated SellerLost Lovey Store is one of eBay's most reputable sellers. Consistently delivers outstanding customer service Learn more

Store policies

Shipping

Feedback ratings

Last 12 months

Positive141- positive feedback in last 12 months
Neutral0- neutral feedback in last 12 months
Negative0- negative feedback in last 12 months

Detailed seller ratings

Average for the last 12 months

Accurate description
5.0
Reasonable shipping cost
5.0
Shipping speed
5.0
Communication
5.0

Seller feedback (7,297)

n***g (234)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Perfect. Just as described. Clean and carefully shipped. Great seller.
o***6 (554)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Quick shipping. Safely packaged. Arrived as described. Would buy from again. Thank you
s***e (12)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past year
Verified purchase
Item came as described and packaged thoughtfully! Shipping time was fast as well. I had this plush as a child and lost it so I’m glad to have one again <3 Thank you so much I appreciate it! I would definitely buy from this seller again!
r***b (1)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
El artículo era exactamente igual a la fotografía, incluso mucho mejor en mis manos. La entrega fue rápida y venía empacado delicadamente. El artículo estaba muy limpio y en perfectas condiciones.
3***t (55)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Great seller. Very communicative and item exactly as described
2***- (870)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past year
Verified purchase
This item is wonderful. Exactly as described. Very fast shipping. Terrific packing. Very trustworthy seller to purchase from. 
See all feedback