Skip to main content
Lost Lovey Store

Lost Lovey Store

17K items sold
254 followers
Contact

Featured categories

Newly Listed

See all

  • Estella NYC Pretzel Baby Rattle Organic Cotton Plush Brown Knit Peru

    $19.99

  • Plush This Moose Belongs to Me Stuffed Animal 14" Kohls Cares for Kids Jeffers

    $17.99

  • Vintage NFL JC Penney Curtain Panel Fabric Houston Oilers Football

    $24.99

  • Guess How Much I Love You Bunny Hugging Baby Lovey Crinkle Brown Kids Preferred

    $29.99

  • Carters Puppy Dog Baby Lovey Plush Blue Brown Plaid 2005 Style 39455 Small

    $14.99

  • Wishpets Blue Elephant ROXY Stuffed Animal Lovey Plush Toy 2012 Rare

    $39.99

All items

Gund Furful MOUSE Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Gray White 60452 Chubby 9"

$29.99

Jellycat Rumpus Puppy Dog Rattle Cream Brown Spots Small 8" Plush Baby Lovey Toy

$29.99

Princess Soft Toys Plush Elephant Baby Lovey Stuffed Animal Safari Blue Purple

$14.99

Mary Meyer Elephant Baby Rattle Plush Birdy Boo New Small 6" Pink Green Birds

$14.99

Disney Parks EWOK Wicket Star Wars Plush Doll 10" Stuffed Toy Brown

$19.99

Vintage NFL JC Penney Curtain Panel Fabric Houston Oilers Football

$24.99

Vintage Lee Wards Christmas Ornament Kit Sealed 1973 Medallion Mini Beaded

$26.9910% off

Carters Puppy Dog Baby Lovey Plush Blue Brown Plaid 2005 Style 39455 Small

$14.99

House Of Hatten The Spirit Of Gifting Jule Nisse Santa Scandinavian Elf 1992

$54.99

Vintage Baby Security Blanket White Thermal Lovey Mini Morgan Satin Trim 20x21"

$53.9910% off

Bobo Buddies Elephant Plush Baby Teether Toy Gray Blue Edgar

$12.99

Bath & Body Works Vanilla Birch 3-Wick Candle 14.5 oz

$26.9910% off

Plan Toys Bunny Racing Car Wood Wooden Sustainable Baby Push Toy Developmental

$22.99

Carters Child Little Blanket of Mine Security Baby Lovey Navy Blue Minky Dots

$17.99

Baby Gap Teddy Bear Brannan Brown Plush Lovey 13" Stuffed Toy Vintage

$22.99

Passover Needlepoint Canvas Judaica Jewish Art Made in Austria Vintage

$17.9910% off

Wild Bill's Olde Fashioned Soda Pop Mini Doll Plush Cowboy Promo Advertising

$14.99

Huntington Home Aldi Retractable Bamboo Wood Wall Coat Hook Natural New Torn Box

$33.2910% off

Carters Just One Year Puppy Baby Lovey Rattle Plush Prestige Tan Blue Check Bow

$17.9910% off

Blankets and Beyond Pink Bunny Security Baby Lovey Gray Eyes Nose Rosette Swirl

$19.99

Estella NYC Pretzel Baby Rattle Organic Cotton Plush Brown Knit Peru

$19.99

Little Giraffe Blue Baby Blanket Deluxe Velvet Satin Plush 29" x 35 Made in USA

$44.9910% off

Circo Elephant Security Blanket Baby Lovey Gray Stripes Target

$15.2910% off

Angel Dear Giraffe Security Blanket Baby Lovey Plush Brown Lot of 2 Pair

$17.0910% off

Tololo FOX Plush Baby Rattle Clip on Toy Black & White Chime Jingbao

$19.99

Guess How Much I Love You Bunny Hugging Baby Lovey Crinkle Brown Kids Preferred

$29.99

Garanimals Baby Blanket Green Thermal Waffle Weave Cotton

$22.4910% off

Security Blanket Baby Lovey Gray Velour Satin Plain 14x14" Square Mini

$13.4910% off

Thomas Kinkade Plush Bunny Yellow Floral Mini Small 6" Stuffed Animal Toy

$13.4910% off

Mary Meyer Noodles Moose Cotton Club Plush Blue Green Mini 5" Rare 1997 Vintage

$26.9910% off

Texas Rangers Golden Chick Dot Race Plush Set 2022 SGA Green Red Blue Lot of 3

$49.99

Nijntje Miffy Bunny Rattle Plush Stuffed Baby Toy Pink White 7"

$24.99

Little Beginnings Blue Bear Security Blanket Baby Lovey Embossed Chevron Zig Zag

$22.4910% off

Plush This Moose Belongs to Me Stuffed Animal 14" Kohls Cares for Kids Jeffers

$17.99

Sigikid Dog Hand Puppet Puppy Dachshund SEPPL Soft Plush My Little Theater

$34.99

Stephan Baby Bunny Security Blanket Lovey Pink Sherpa Stephen

$14.99

Vintage Bucilla Cross Stitch Belgian Oyster Linen 4 Napkins Needlework Kit

$13.4910% off

Kaloo Bunny Baby Lovey Yellow Gray Chubby Stuffed Animal Small 5"

$17.9910% off

Playskool Teddy Bear Sweet Beginnings Puffalump Nylon Plush Vintage

$13.4910% off

SDA Vtg Adventist Hospital Chefs Cookbook Dining Delightfully Vegetarian Recipes

$43.1910% off

Nat and Jules Teddy Bear Pink Camo Baby Regan Plush Rattle Lovey 9" Camouflage

$13.4910% off

Koala Baby CUTE AS A BUG Baby Blanket Blue Plush Caterpillar 2010

$35.9910% off

Mud Pie FOX Security Blanket Plush Baby Lovey Wood Teething Ring 13'

$13.4910% off

Vintage Krumples Family Play Group Dog Hobo Reversible Purple Orange 1980s Plush

$26.9910% off

Fiesta Elephant Mod Squad Plush Stuffed Animal Colorful Polka Dots 18" New

$39.99

Jellycat Bunglie PANDA Teddy Bear Plush Lovey Stuffed Animal Toy 16" Black White

$53.9910% off

Wishpets Blue Elephant ROXY Stuffed Animal Lovey Plush Toy 2012 Rare

$39.99

Zweigart Hearthside 14 ct 16x16 large pillow cover Craftworld cross stitch

$13.4910% off
Items Per Page
See All

About us

Welcome to The Lost Lovey Store! I'm here to help you find that item your child just can't live without! I offer baby blankets, security blankets, baby loveys, plush toys, and stuffed animals--things that are so important to our little ones. My inventory usually contains vintage baby blankets and plush toys as well, because no matter how old we get, sometimes it's delightful to have a nostalgic piece of our childhood. Can't find what you're looking for? Let me know, and I might be able to help you. Check back often; I add new inventory almost every day!
Location: United StatesMember since: Oct 07, 2001Seller: adorable*and*affordable
Top Rated SellerLost Lovey Store is one of eBay's most reputable sellers. Consistently delivers outstanding customer service Learn more

Store policies

Shipping

Feedback ratings

Last 12 months

Positive149- positive feedback in last 12 months
Neutral0- neutral feedback in last 12 months
Negative0- negative feedback in last 12 months

Detailed seller ratings

Average for the last 12 months

Accurate description
5.0
Reasonable shipping cost
5.0
Shipping speed
5.0
Communication
5.0

Seller feedback (7,293)

n***g (234)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past month
Verified purchase
Perfect. Just as described. Clean and carefully shipped. Great seller.
s***e (12)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Item came as described and packaged thoughtfully! Shipping time was fast as well. I had this plush as a child and lost it so I’m glad to have one again <3 Thank you so much I appreciate it! I would definitely buy from this seller again!
o***6 (540)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Quick shipping. Safely packaged. Arrived as described. Would buy from again. Thank you
r***b (1)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
El artículo era exactamente igual a la fotografía, incluso mucho mejor en mis manos. La entrega fue rápida y venía empacado delicadamente. El artículo estaba muy limpio y en perfectas condiciones.
3***t (55)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past month
Verified purchase
Great seller. Very communicative and item exactly as described
2***- (831)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past year
Verified purchase
This item is wonderful. Exactly as described. Very fast shipping. Terrific packing. Very trustworthy seller to purchase from. 
See all feedback