Skip to main content
Natalie Ever After

Natalie Ever After

4.5K items sold
50 followers
Contact

Featured categories

Newly Listed

See all

  • Scentsy Wax Warmer Full Winter Reindeer Snowflake Holiday Collection Retired

    $25.99

  • Man Laws and Woman Rules Adult Board Game NEW Sealed

    $15.00

  • Farkle Game The Classic Dice-Rolling, Risk-Taking Game 2016 Strategy NEW Sealed

    $12.99

  • Hasbro Monopoly Game Cheaters Edition Board Game New Sealed

    $15.00

  • Taggies Baby Security Blankets And Toys Assorted Lot of Plush Toys

    $18.00

  • Justice Girls Sequined Aqua Translucent Mini Backpack

    $22.00

All items

Barbie Clothes Lot Variety of 8 Pairs of Shorts and Capris Modern and Vintage

$10.00

Barbie Clothes Large Lot Variety of 7 Skirts Modern and Vintage Mixed

$14.00

Scentsy Wax Warmer Full Winter Reindeer Snowflake Holiday Collection Retired

$25.99

Barbie You Can Be A Fashionista Vinyl Carry Case 13” x 10.5” Storage w/ 2 Dolls

$13.99

Taggies Baby Security Blankets And Toys Assorted Lot of Plush Toys

$18.00

Barbie Clothes Large Lot Variety of 6 Skirts Modern and Vintage Mixed

$12.00

Studio His & Hers Cake Topper Wedding Black Studded Word Love

$10.00

AQ Organizational Divided Metal Tin Caddy with Hinged Lid & Removable Tray Black

$30.00

Scentsy Buddy Roarbert Lion Plush Stuffed Animal 15" Plus 2 Scentsy Packs EUC

$12.00

New Manhattan Toy Company Plush Savanna Monkey Baby Toy Tactile Development 10"

$9.99

New My First Shape Sorter Green Toys 10 pcs 100% Recycled Plastic USA Made

$16.99

Schylling Plush Sock Monkey Knitted Pink 7" EUC

$8.00

Scentsy Rustic Cork Full Size Warmer Discontinued Teal

$19.99

Ulta Beauty Weekender Gray Faux Leather Backpack Purse NEW

$14.00

Barbie Clothes Lot Variety of 4 Princess Skirts and Jasmine Pants Modern Mixed

$8.00

Build A Bear Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Leonardo 18” Plush Toy Nickelodeon

$11.00

Barbie Clothes Lot Variety of 4 Disney Princess Dresses

$17.99

Cabbage Patch Kids Cuties Doll Lot of 3 Cat, Pig and Goat RARE 10"

$18.99

Barbie Clothes Lot Variety of 4 Disney Princess Dresses

$17.99

Ashley Belle Collection Porcelain Doll Apple Limited Edition NEW Fine Bisque

$15.00

Hedbanz Board Game New Sealed by Spinmaster Question Game 7+

$10.00

Barbie Clothes Lot Variety of 3 Fancy Dresses

$13.00

Jellycat Fuddlewuddle Plush Puppy Dog Medium 9" Brown Stuffed Toy RARE

$14.00

Barbie Clothes Lot Variety of 3 Capris Pants Mixed

$7.00

Sanrio Hello Kitty Plush in Bunny Costume 13" Sitting Large Stuffed Toy Rare

$14.00

Justice Girls Sequined Aqua Translucent Mini Backpack

$22.00

AURORA BABY Elephant Plush Baby Rattle Gray Polka Dot Feet 7" EUC Lovey Soft

$8.00

My Little Pony Fluttershy Mini 5.5" Plush 2016 New Yellow Pink Butterflies

$9.99

NEW Scentsy Buddy Plush Sasha The Bear Red Shirt Stuffed Animal Scent Holder 15"

$14.99

Flower Power Kids Costume Hippie Halloween 60's 70's Dress Up Size Small 3-4 NEW

$5.99

Barbie Clothes Lot of Princess Skirts plus Interchangeable Mermaid Skirt Mixed

$9.00

Barbie Clothes Lot of 7 Variety of Skinny Pants, Capris, Leggings, and Pants

$16.00

Vera Bradley Burgundy Tote Bohemian Chevron Retired Print RARE

$15.99

Disney Parks Plush Pluto Rattle Christmas Santa 11" Sitting Baby Toy RARE EUC

$12.99

Cabbage Patch Kids Cuties Doll Lot of 2 Unicorn Friernds RARE 10"

$13.00

Disney Store Plush Pluto Green Collar with Name Laying Stuffed Toy 15" EUC

$9.99

Mary Meyer Elephant Plush White w/ Multicolored Flowers and Birds 12” Lovey Toy

$11.00

Barbie Clothes Lot Variety of 6 Vintage Skirts Mixed

$11.00

Buzz Lightyear Plush Toy Story Disney Parks Original Plush 11.5" Beanie Feet

$8.00

Living Textiles Theodore Elephant Crochet Baby Toy Beige Plush w/ Rattle 13”

$8.00

Baby Belle Plush Pink Teddy Bear Stuffed Toy RARE Gold Bow Textured Fur EUC

$9.00

Baby GUND Developmental Play Teach Me Plush Giraffe Pink 14" #59198 RARE

$16.99

Little Miracles Puppy Dog Tan Round and Chubby Plush Stuffed Baby Toy Lovey 13"

$18.00

Disneyland Resorts Princess Minnie Mouse 12" Plush Toy Pink Princess Dress

$12.00

Disney Store 12" Thumper Plush Bunny Bambi Sitting Position Super Plushy Soft

$9.00

Scentsy Buddy Gage The Robot Plush 15" Scent Holder Silver No Pak Retired

$12.99

Care Bears Plush Love-A-Lot Bear Pink Tye Dye Beanie Stuffed Toy RARE 8" 2003

$8.00

Disney Parks Authentic Classic Mickey Mouse Plush 13" Original Stuffed Toy

$9.99
Items Per Page
See All

About us

Natalie Ever After specializes in Disney Items, Baby Toys, Baby Items, Toys, Home Décor, Clothing, Shoes, Accessories, Coffee Mugs, Gifts, Kitchen Items, Housewares, Sporting Goods and more. I only sell new or gently used items. Costumer service and satisfaction is very important to me. If you have any questions about an item, feel free to ask. I strive to meet the needs of my buyers with quick communication. If you have any problems, please contact me first immediately! Enjoy shopping! Thank you for your business!
Location: United StatesMember since: Sep 13, 2010Seller: natalieeverafter10

Store policies

Returns

Feedback ratings

Last 12 months

Positive9- positive feedback in last 12 months
Neutral1- neutral feedback in last 12 months
Negative0- negative feedback in last 12 months

Seller feedback (1,822)

e***e (91)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Shipped quickly and is exactly like the listing. Thank you!
l***a (208)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past month
Verified purchase
Trustworthy seller. 5 stars!
r***6 (13)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past year
Verified purchase
Everything came in great, it arrived fast, and there was a lot of care into making sure the item was well packed and secure!
i***f (263)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past year
Verified purchase
Great transaction! Item received quickly and was exactly as described. Thanks.
_***s (61)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past year
Verified purchase
Slow with shipping. And doesn’t respond to messages
Reply from: natalieeverafter10- Feedback replied by seller natalieeverafter10.- Feedback replied by seller natalieeverafter10.
No messages were sent to me by this buyer. Item was delayed due to Postal Service neglect. Sorry to hear they were not 100% satisfied.
d***k (2298)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past month
Verified purchase
good deal
See all feedback